Press and Testimonials
BOOK YOUR STAY  t. 800-585-4461|t. 908-221-1100

Press and Testimonials

Press Testimonials
27
Sat
Nov
2021

November,2021:Trip Advisor

Charming Inn
The Old Mill Inn is a charming and beautifully decorated hotel. The staff is professional and friendly and rooms very comfortable. We especially like the extra sink outside the bathroom and large desk. The continental breakfast has many options and plenty of space to accommodate all guests. We will be returning in the months to come.
22
Mon
Nov
2021

November,2021:Trip Advisor

Review from Nov 10, 2021
If you want an excellent meeting come to the Olde Mill Inn!!
This is the 4th time I’ve hosted a meeting at OMI. October 2020 was the last one prior. I will continue to host my Executive Offsite meetings here because the level of customer service is the highest I’ve ever received. I am responsible for many meetings and this hotel far surpasses every expectation. When my C level executives are happy, then I’m happy. From accommodating the requirements for a safe and socially distanced meeting, to the extremely clean rooms, to the fabulous food at the Grain House, it is all 5 star. The GM has his finger on the pulse of what is going on and my sales representative, Lindsey is on top of anything and everything during the entire meeting. If you are an EA or Event planner, this is the place that will make you shine! Alan will greet your guests with a warm smile and Betsy at the Grain House will make you and your guests feel welcome!
One of the great things to do in the evening is to stop by the front desk, where you will find Michael, who is the most pleasant person and quite accommodating, grab a bottle of wine and head out the back to the fireplace and relax!! We had quite a crowd out there for two nights. It was a wonderful place to unwind after a 9 hour meeting!! I can’t wait to return!
10
Wed
Nov
2021

November,2021:Trip Advisor

Wedding Venue
Very impressed with my entire stay at your beautiful scenic Olde Mill Inn. Food was excellent along with the entire staff. My room had a balcony overlooking the courtyard which was gorgeous. My daughter’s wedding was held in the grain house which was beautifully decorated with the fireplace giving a cozy atmosphere. Thank you for a fantastic experience.
13
Fri
Mar
2020

March, 2020: WeddingWire.com (posted by Karolina R.)

Amazing experience at this venue

Choosing the Grain House at the Olde Mill Inn for our wedding ceremony and reception was the best decision we made. We wanted an all inclusive wedding, in a cozy location with lots of good food and drinks. We got exactly that and more. Our maître d’ John Lietz was so great to work with. He answered every question we had, helped us coordinate with vendors, helped us navigate the menu and other selections. One of the biggest perks was that John and his staff set up all decorations (minus live florals) so we barely had to lift a finger. All we had to do was drop off boxes with any favors, decorations, seating chart, etc, and they took care of the rest. We didn’t want to have friends or family do any work during our wedding day, we just wanted them to enjoy it. That’s what a stress-free wedding is all about. After the reception was over our decorations were packed up and were waiting in our suite along with the top tier of our cake, and a bottle of champagne and strawberries on our bed. And yes, a huge suite on the wedding night is included too.

Our guests also raved about how much amazing food there was. The cocktail hour food was delicious. The open bar is fully stocked. John also worked with us on the timing of the reception so out guests can dance between the appetizer and the dinner entree and the cake cutting. Our cake was also included in our price and we got to pick from two different bakeries. The service all throughout the reception was impeccable. Guests were tended to promptly and some of them told us how amazing the service is. John was with us all day and made sure we never needed anything. At cocktail hour, he brought us plates of hors d’oeuvres to make sure we ate. They took care of us so well it truly make us feel very special on our day.

We really can’t rave enough about what a wonderful experience we had having our wedding here. Our guests loved it, we loved it, and we can’t recommend it enough

12
Wed
Feb
2020

January, 2020: WeddingWire.com (posted by Wendy G.)

Excellent Wedding Service

My daughter’s wedding was at the Grain House on January 11, 2020. I can not say enough to express how professional and experienced all the staff members were. A special shout out to our maitre d Gabe and our table side server Carlos. From food to rooms to service everything was excellent!!!

20
Wed
Mar
2019

March, 2019: WeddingWire.com (posted by Jennifer P.)

Best day ever!  Our wedding was the absolute perfect day. The olde mill inn is the best place you could ever imagine. The food was amazing, everyone keeps telling us that it was one of the best weddings they have ever been too. John was our maitre d and he was the best. He kept everything running smoothly the whole time. Our rehearsal dinner was at the restaurant grain house and it was just as amazing. We can not thank Olde Mill Inn enough for everything we imagined and more.

22
Fri
Feb
2019

February, 2019: Knot.com (posted by Mackenzie E.)

We got married at the Grain House a few weeks ago and could not have been happier with the experience. We planned the wedding over less than 6 months from out of state, and Lindsay and Gabriel could not have been more helpful. I keep hearing how beautiful the venue is and how delicious the food was. We couldn’t have chosen a more perfect place to celebrate.

14
Thu
Feb
2019

February, 2019: Knot.com (posted by Christine P.)

Wow where do I begin? Lindsay Stewart was our sales person. Any questions we had she was quick to answer and was willing to work with us. The Olde Mill Inn is absolutely beautiful inside and outside. Our matre’d John Lietz was fantastic. Every single review we read about him is true-HE IS THAT GOOD. I wish I could give this venue 10 stars because honestly 5 is not enough. Our guests kept raving about the venue, cocktail hour, dinner, the service. So many people asked how we found such a beautiful venue. The service was excellent. Many guests said they didn’t even have to get up to go to the bar, drinks were being brought to them. Cocktail hour was amazing:mini chicken and waffles, grilled cheese/tomato soup shooter, beef wellington. My girls and I got ready in the suite, wow was it beautiful and huge! The hotel staff is fantastic, the courtyard is amazing day or night. I would absolutely recommend Olde Mill Inn to everyone and anyone I know. It was better then our wildest dreams. We are SO sad it is over, but our hope is that we get to be a guest at a wedding at Olde Mill Inn

11
Fri
Jan
2019

January, 2019: WeddingWire.com (posted by Ashlee)

Gabriel is the best! The night was perfect. Perfect! Not one thing went wrong…nothing! Gabriel was amazing and so attentive to not just us but to our families as well. The staff at our wedding was the best. Drinks in hand at all times before you realized you needed one! The food was amazing as well as the desserts! I really can’t thank them all enough for making our day truly so magical and special and of course all about us! The hotel is so accommodating, from the breakfast to the bridal rooms! You will not be disappointed 💕

24
Sat
Nov
2018

November, 2018: WeddingWire.com (posted by Gina)

Book this venue!  I am beyond happy with having our reception at the Grain House at the Olde Mill Inn. The style of the building is so cute and vintage exactly what I love. We had our reception in the Hunt Room with about 89 people. The size of the room was perfect for the amount of guests we had. The staff was amazing especially our Matrie’D. They made everything go so smoothly and perfect. There was not one thing I would change about our day. Also the food was amazing everyone enjoyed it. I think the most convenient part about having our reception here is that our guests got to stay at the olde mill inn which was fantastic, nobody had to worry about shuttles or anything. I would recommend this place to anybody you will not regret it.